Thursday, August 10, 2006

Can a film's fate be predicted before its release?

Can someone predict that a couple is going to get divorced by listening them talk to each other for an hour ?

John Gottman, a researcher of University of Washington, can predict it for American couples with 95% accuracy. He has published it in a book called The Mathematics of divorce.

When someone is trying to 'unravel' a 'whole' like a relationship, one can employ two ways. One can break the 'whole' into simple components and try to 'strengthen' each of the elements, sequentially or simultaneously. Or one can view the 'whole' in a 'systemic' way, and find out a different 'way' of viewing the whole that can 'explain' that 'whole system' in a better way.

John Gottman took the second approach to predict a relationship graph of a couple. He viewed the 'whole' through a different window of +ve emotion and -ve emotion, and found that if the +ve emotions in a conversation are 'x' multiple of -ve emotion, then the relationship between the two people can be predicted.

One can employ a similar technique while 'evaluating' a whole, called 'Movie'. One can bifurcate a movie into different components like marketing, story-engaging capability and style of movie presentation. Each component can then be understood as a 'whole' and coupled together to predict a movie's success or failure.

It seems Ramesh Sarda, a professor of Oklahama State University, has gone this route and found out the clues of how marketing affects a movies success, and developed his predictive model. He developed concepts of 'prosumer' - a common concept of advertising - to make his point.

I also know of another researcher, Ravi Reddy (also from US), who has tried to evaluate the movie's impact on the audience through 'measuring' emotions of an audience. He has tried to use the new science of bioinformatics to measure the audience response directly by putting electrodes on the brain and other parts of the body. Here the idea is to measure the impact of the two elements - story engaging capability and style of presenting the movie - by measuring the 'emotional response' of an individual.

But both these researchers are trying to 'catch' the horse after it has bolted from the stable. One can predict a movie's success only after considerable money has been invested. It would be more effective if we can predict success of a movie after a script is ready. This is what Madhur Bhandarkar seem to have asked in the TOI news of 10 August, 'Can one predict a movies success after a script is ready?". My humble answer to that is yes.

One can do it by taking two actions:

  • Develop a method to understand the story-engaging capability of a movie. This can be done by marrying 'literature principles' with 'systemic thinking'. Both the bodies of knowledge are ready and available. One needs a person to marry them both. This is fairly 'simple' task, a task of 2 months.
  • Use a trained and experienced 'director' - like Madhur Bhandarkar or Ram Gopal Verma - to understand how the story written in a 'specific' way can be converted into a movie. This can be done by an experienced director. Once again, an appropriately trained director can unravel this code in a short period, say 2 months.

Both the above actions require an ability to 'unravel' the whole 'movie' without breaking 'whole' into components. And therefore it requires experience and technical knowledge together.

However, if we can bring these two components together, we could definitely built a 'method' of predicting a movie-success with a probabilty of say 70% or more. Naturally, such methods are part 'science' and part 'art'. But with experience, the predictability can be increased to even higher rates.

This will not only help us make good movies, but will also help us rope in better financers for movie. This will prevent the wastage of money in movie projects. This will increase the ability of a movie to fetch back normal returns.

All this knowledge is available in India. It may not be available in movie industry, but is available in corporate India.

Does any one in a movie industry have courage to follow this path? With more professionalisation, i am sure someone will have the courage to bell the tiger.

Monday, July 03, 2006

Why systems thinking for Movie making

A movie maker spends time, effort and money to make a movie. Movies are made either to make a point, or simply to entertain. Although one can argue which is a better purpose of making a movie, one can hardly argue that art of movie-making is about telling good effective stories. The story is of a love being found, or a treasure being discovered, or a serious event of a man trying to discover himself.
The media of stage and movie are different, but both are trying to tell good engaging story. And therefore, despite differences, both share a common challenge: a challenge of telling 'good engaging story'.
On the other hand, when an audience is watching a movie, he or she comes with a different objective, different background of social, economic and personal beliefs, different knowledge and skills, different maturity, different expectation, and differing intensity of issues.
Engaging such a diverse audience in a story is enabling them to move from 'their system' to the 'director's system'. As the audience becomes part of a director's system, they empathise with the story, become part of it, share the emotions of the protagonist and antagonist, and live with them. If this process of moving from one system to another is graceful, the audience likes the story. This liking is converted into cash register.
Whether the story is presenting a theme of love, or telling a serious message of AIDS, the method of engaging the diverse audience is not different. When the director knows the process of moving audience from one system to another, he or she can engage the audience effectively. That is why a good serious movie like Page 3 can be as engaging as a love story of Gaddar.
Systems thinking therefore enables a director/writer to incorporate all the elements that will help audience move from one system to another system. In this blog we shall write about the elements that a maker of a movie or drama either follow or inadvertently ignore. We shall use the real-life current movies to explore the ideas of systems thinking .