Monday, August 27, 2007

Evaluating a movie by a layman

Last week, I watched Fanaa on the TV with my friend. I asked my friend how did she find the movie. She said the 'First half was good. Second half was boring'. After I asked her to state the reasons, she started giving me various reasons: the confusion of what the director wanted to achieve, the obvious missing links in the death of the heroine's father and her sighting of the body, obvious contradictions in her running away from her house to the Colonel's house and then opening the door instantly when the hero comes to the Colonel's house. The reasons were galore.

Can a movie be evaluated by an audience? Yes, the movie can be rated as good, bad, average by the audience. But can a layman give the exact reasons of why the movie he or she found as 'bad'? It is like evaluating a person whom you have seen for the first time in a mall. More often than not, we rate the person first as 'good' or 'bad' and then find reasons to justify why the person was good or bad. Psychologist call this passive sensemaking. We select 'evidence' that suits our conclusion.

I met a producer of a very successful movie. When i asked his reasons why that movie clicked, he felt that it was because the movie showed many things for the first time, such as the duality of Page 3 audience and so on. When i gave him an example of another not-so-successful movie 'Tango Charlie' which also showed many novel things for the first time, he did not reply. Not so surprisingly, his second movie with the same director and crew failed at the box office. When Farhan Akthar was asked in a TV interview why his second movie 'Lakhshya' did not run well, ( after his smash hit of Dil chahta Hai) he was candid enough to say that 'he does not know the reason'.


This is what happens when individuals evaluate a 'whole' by looking at the fragments. One can evaluate a movie only as a whole. And one has to be trained to see the movie as a whole. A lay audience can only tell you whether they liked or not, but you need a trained expert in 'wholistic' systems to evaluate a movie. So whether you are evaluating Rang de basanti, Eklavya, Chakde, or Honeymoon travels, you need to get trained appropriately.

The same is true about evaluating an organisation as a whole. Business analysts are so eager to evaluate a company from its 'ad campaign' or its 'announced strategy' that they can rarely understand why that company runs well.