Tuesday, December 25, 2007

Tare Zameen Par - A missed opportunity

I saw TZP on Saturday. It is a good movie. It tells a story of a dyslexic child. Because his parents and teachers do not understand his handicap, he goes through a very difficult period of learning and almost gives up. His saviour in the form of teacher helps him get back to his path. Story is narrated in an engaging manner, although the second half is less gripping. It connects emotionally though; which is perhaps the biggest plus point.

It could however been a big movie though; if it had embraced a much more universal theme. Big movies work on two themes ( or think them as two layers): one is a simple plot theme which has to engage the audience, and another is a much more deeper universal theme which has to connect to a deeper and universal truth. Raj Kapoor's movies use this very intelligently.

For instance, RK's Ram Teri Ganga Maili works with two themes: one is the theme of a girl who trusts and gives up everything for her love, and another much more universal theme of how Indians have polluted a pure river ( both physically and metaphorically speaking). He keeps these two themes parallel, and holds on to them till the end. That is why his movies always resonate with a larger audience.

TZP works with one theme: a dyslexic child, much misunderstood, and then resurrected by a teacher. Other universal theme it touches at various points is 'how parents completely misunderstand their children and treat them as vehicles of their ambitions'. The story of elder brother Yohan deals with it, but surreptitiously. It touches the theme, but does not dare to embrace it.

Because the movie does not embrace the second universal theme, audience conclude that the story is about a dyslexic child: not about every parent's relationship with his/her child. In the process, it leaves many untangled loose ends, and worse still, it misses the opportunity of using it to connect with a larger audience.

For instance, when the parent asks the teacher " How could i let ishaan learn painting only, because that would have meant i would have to take his care throughout his life'. This is a question every parent has. Do they let their children learn something which looks like a hobby? Is that right? Infact one of the parent commented to me that TZP is a nice story, but impractical. Connection is lost, and therefore the audience.

On the other hand, if Aamir khan would have taken this universal theme to tell the main story, it would have looked like a 'lecture'. Aamir khan's plot of dyslexic child is therefore necessary to engage the audience. But if Aamir khan had simultaneously carried the universal theme the movie would have connected to a bigger audience, and therefore a big hit.

Aamir khan was so close but so far. For a short time, i thought he was carrying the universal theme parallelly when the sequence of Yohan losing the tennis match was being shown. But alas, i was wrong. I wish he had done it differently.

Friday, December 14, 2007

Brilliance in techniques does not make a movie

I recently saw Sawariya. It is a wonderful shot movie on a set which is a completely man made. It has new actors who have performed above expectations. It has songs which are melodious. But it is not a movie, because it lacks the basic ingredient that makes a movie: it does not tell a story in an engaging manner.

Some directors, who become accomplished, confuse movie making with the parts of movie making. Cinematography, music and acting are the 'part elements' of movie making, which individually could be brilliant. But if they do not produce the coherent whole , which is engaging story, then what comes out is not a movie. It is a piece of art that serves a different purpose.

In the 70's, directors used to confuse ' plot of story' with art movie. For instance, story of a rural villager or of land exploitation was supposed to be a good art movie, while a story of a 'hero meeting a heroine' in a town was supposed to be a commercial movie. Plot of a story however has no relevance to a movie maker. Satyajit Ray's movies are a very good examples of this.

Whatever be the plot, socially-relevant or not, has to be told in an engaging manner. If a movie director fails in this primary objective, then it is better to realise that he or she has failed to make a good movie. It may be a good piece of art, but not a movie.