Saturday, July 27, 2013

The Naked Island - Watch this movie that showed the 'struggle' and make you feel it

Yesterday, i saw this Japanese Movie of 1960, directed by Kaneto Shindo. It is amazing because of four reasons: 




1> The director has the audacity to chose a theme that is almost impossible to show on the screen. The theme is "Despite huge struggles to live, life still goes on". Protagonist of theme is the farmer living in an island where there is no water. The family ( consisting of husband, wife and two sons) has to bring in water from a nearby town everyday in a boat even to meet their daily needs like taking bath or drinking water. And then we are surprised to see that they also are carrying water to feed the the plants on which they are subsisting. The struggle is of physical survival, something an Indian farmer in the hinterland can still identify himself with. 

2> The film has no spoken dialogue. Although there is background music, the silence is deliberate. Only later, we discover the powerful impact of silence.  The silence mirrors the patience and the hard work of a farmer and, like him, we tend to understand that one cannot expect swift results in life. Even the children are shown doing their household tasks without being told so. The director seem to have made the actors actually carry the huge water, because we can see the struggle of the man/woman in trying to grip the ground, in maintaining the balance between the two pots of water. Silence makes us imagine their thoughts and struggle better than anyone can tell us. And therefore it contributes greatly to the film’s stoic attitude to the hardships of life.

3> The film has a simple plot. Entire plot conveys the same theme again and again. For instance, after the harvest when the farmer and his wife takes it to the nearby town, they just keep the harvest infront of the house of some 'rich agent' and walk way, not even negotiating the price of harvest. Or when the son catches a big fish, the family is very happy. However, when they are eating their food in a restaurant ( as part of their celebration), their manner of eating is very 'workman-like'. They seem to be knowing that struggle is still to continue.

4> And in the climax, when one of the son dies, the despair is shown in the wife. She breaks down. She kicks the pot of water and spills the entire water after carrying it for miles, and then removes the plants from the earth. We can sense her despairing thought, "How long can I go on living like this? Is there an end to this?" With no words from her mouth, we can almost read the thoughts in her mind. 


I remembered Irving Wallace, the famous novelist, who said that " Written novels can never be converted into good films, because films cannot use your imagination like written novels can". But when you watch this Kaneto Shindo's movie, Naked Island, you realise that he proved this wrong. 


Conclusion


And although the movie plot portrays physical struggle', the movie's theme is still relevant today. Only the nature of struggle has changed. Today, our struggle in the modern 21st century is more 'mental'. We are not seeking physical comfort. That phase of life is over. We are seeking mental comfort. For instance, we want to find job satisfaction in our life, or do something significant in life, or leave behind some legacy. And, like the farmer in Naked Island, we continue to 'Live our Life despite the struggles, pains, failures, and the hiccups'. 


Today, because the struggle is 'mental', one cannot see this struggle in the open. One can at least watch the physical struggle and empathise with a person, but how can one empathise with a person whose mental struggle can be seen only by himself. If Kaneto Shindo was called in to direct a movie to show this acute'mental struggle', which many students suffer either due to their school negligence or parental expectations, how would he have shown? 

Monday, January 24, 2011

Dhobi Ghat - Power of theme in movie making

Dhobi Ghat, a film directed by Kiran Rao, is a good movie. Characterisation is excellent, plot/story about four different characters is equally good, style of presenting is equally wonderful. Many facets of the movie are excellent: Weaving of four characters, intelligent use of the video of a girl as an intrigue, use of Zoib's character to keep the story engaging.

But it lacks just one thing - Theme. Without a theme, the movie seems to be a documentary.

Theme is an often invisible in a movie. But any good movie ( and more so if it becomes popular) always has a underlying theme to which the entire plot/character/style has to align. Sometimes this theme is mentioned in a line of a character in a movie( like in 3 idiots), sometimes it has to be deciphered. 3 idiots became popular because it's central theme is so clearly brought out through the story. This line given to Aamir Khan ' Kabliyat ke piche Daudo, shohrat khud-b-khud tumaraa pichaa karegi' captures the movies theme very aptly. Entire structure of movie is built around that central theme.

Raj kapoor's movies were popular because his central theme was presented through two plots: one a social plot, and another a story plot. Example of Ram Teri Ganga Maili is an excellent example of this.

Dhobi Ghat lacks this central theme. Let us take an example of a theme that would have connected with the audience,such as, 'Mumbai helps everyone to realise their dreams irrespective of its bottlenecks'. End of movie could have strengthened this theme, but changes in certain dialogues would be needed to bring out his theme starkly. The story of fourth character ( the character of girl who commits suicide) would not have fitted this theme. Some changes would have been needed in the movie to make the above theme work.

That is what a theme does to the movie. It clearly brings out what is 'right and logical' in a movie and what is not. It provides consistency to the characters. It anchors the plot. And above all, in the mind of a audience, it connects with something bigger in life.

Friday, February 19, 2010

MNIK - a lost opportunity of conveying a powerful theme

The movie starts with a wonderful scene at the airport security. When Rizwan, the hero, is asked by the police what he wants to tell the President, he says " My name is Khan & I am not a terrorist'. This scene is done with such a finesse that it shakes one up from the stupor. It also carries lot of impact because it perhaps articulates an unspoken thought of each and every individual in a very neat and simple way.

Although the love story is another subplot in the story, subtle seeds of impending climax of movie are also sown at different places in the plot. When Rizwans's child dies due to unexpected but 'inevitable' incident, the story becomes more gripping. This event is a beautiful example of 'how to tell a good story', because within a single event, both the plots converge. The conflict between wife's love and the hero's identity is brought out in the open!

Till, almost the 2/3rd of the movie, the story continues with the minor plot ( love story) subsumed under the main plot( of Hero's identity). Until the TV broadcast of the hero's detainment in the prison, the story grips you with emotion and drama. The event of the TV broadcast would have been appropriate to convey the main theme of MNIK 'My name is Khan and i am not a terrorist' to the president.

But the director suddenly forgets that main plot of the story is of Muslim identity. The director decides that the plot of 'love story' is more important and therefore continues to tell us the story further. It is like our nanny continuing to narrate a murder mystery after the culprit has been caught. One naturally feels bored because one is then hearing the story out of respect to Nanny.

In a movie with such a strong theme, such a mistake is felt strongly because the important message gets 'submerged' under a trivial message. One almost feels cheated because the story, which started with a grand promise, is delivering some other promise.I wish Karan Johar learns the critical elements of a good story-telling. He is so gifted in his ability to capture emotions, portray relationships, deploy camera so beautifully, that one wishes he learns this very simple element of story- telling quickly. I will not be surprised if the movie does not become a 'huge hit' that it deserved to be!

Here is a Quiz for you. Few years back, another director, also made the same mistake:making a movie with two themes, each clashing with other. That movie flopped very badly. But that director had directed his first movie, which was a huge hit. Can you name the director and his second movie which flopped?

Tuesday, December 25, 2007

Tare Zameen Par - A missed opportunity

I saw TZP on Saturday. It is a good movie. It tells a story of a dyslexic child. Because his parents and teachers do not understand his handicap, he goes through a very difficult period of learning and almost gives up. His saviour in the form of teacher helps him get back to his path. Story is narrated in an engaging manner, although the second half is less gripping. It connects emotionally though; which is perhaps the biggest plus point.

It could however been a big movie though; if it had embraced a much more universal theme. Big movies work on two themes ( or think them as two layers): one is a simple plot theme which has to engage the audience, and another is a much more deeper universal theme which has to connect to a deeper and universal truth. Raj Kapoor's movies use this very intelligently.

For instance, RK's Ram Teri Ganga Maili works with two themes: one is the theme of a girl who trusts and gives up everything for her love, and another much more universal theme of how Indians have polluted a pure river ( both physically and metaphorically speaking). He keeps these two themes parallel, and holds on to them till the end. That is why his movies always resonate with a larger audience.

TZP works with one theme: a dyslexic child, much misunderstood, and then resurrected by a teacher. Other universal theme it touches at various points is 'how parents completely misunderstand their children and treat them as vehicles of their ambitions'. The story of elder brother Yohan deals with it, but surreptitiously. It touches the theme, but does not dare to embrace it.

Because the movie does not embrace the second universal theme, audience conclude that the story is about a dyslexic child: not about every parent's relationship with his/her child. In the process, it leaves many untangled loose ends, and worse still, it misses the opportunity of using it to connect with a larger audience.

For instance, when the parent asks the teacher " How could i let ishaan learn painting only, because that would have meant i would have to take his care throughout his life'. This is a question every parent has. Do they let their children learn something which looks like a hobby? Is that right? Infact one of the parent commented to me that TZP is a nice story, but impractical. Connection is lost, and therefore the audience.

On the other hand, if Aamir khan would have taken this universal theme to tell the main story, it would have looked like a 'lecture'. Aamir khan's plot of dyslexic child is therefore necessary to engage the audience. But if Aamir khan had simultaneously carried the universal theme the movie would have connected to a bigger audience, and therefore a big hit.

Aamir khan was so close but so far. For a short time, i thought he was carrying the universal theme parallelly when the sequence of Yohan losing the tennis match was being shown. But alas, i was wrong. I wish he had done it differently.

Friday, December 14, 2007

Brilliance in techniques does not make a movie

I recently saw Sawariya. It is a wonderful shot movie on a set which is a completely man made. It has new actors who have performed above expectations. It has songs which are melodious. But it is not a movie, because it lacks the basic ingredient that makes a movie: it does not tell a story in an engaging manner.

Some directors, who become accomplished, confuse movie making with the parts of movie making. Cinematography, music and acting are the 'part elements' of movie making, which individually could be brilliant. But if they do not produce the coherent whole , which is engaging story, then what comes out is not a movie. It is a piece of art that serves a different purpose.

In the 70's, directors used to confuse ' plot of story' with art movie. For instance, story of a rural villager or of land exploitation was supposed to be a good art movie, while a story of a 'hero meeting a heroine' in a town was supposed to be a commercial movie. Plot of a story however has no relevance to a movie maker. Satyajit Ray's movies are a very good examples of this.

Whatever be the plot, socially-relevant or not, has to be told in an engaging manner. If a movie director fails in this primary objective, then it is better to realise that he or she has failed to make a good movie. It may be a good piece of art, but not a movie.

Monday, August 27, 2007

Evaluating a movie by a layman

Last week, I watched Fanaa on the TV with my friend. I asked my friend how did she find the movie. She said the 'First half was good. Second half was boring'. After I asked her to state the reasons, she started giving me various reasons: the confusion of what the director wanted to achieve, the obvious missing links in the death of the heroine's father and her sighting of the body, obvious contradictions in her running away from her house to the Colonel's house and then opening the door instantly when the hero comes to the Colonel's house. The reasons were galore.

Can a movie be evaluated by an audience? Yes, the movie can be rated as good, bad, average by the audience. But can a layman give the exact reasons of why the movie he or she found as 'bad'? It is like evaluating a person whom you have seen for the first time in a mall. More often than not, we rate the person first as 'good' or 'bad' and then find reasons to justify why the person was good or bad. Psychologist call this passive sensemaking. We select 'evidence' that suits our conclusion.

I met a producer of a very successful movie. When i asked his reasons why that movie clicked, he felt that it was because the movie showed many things for the first time, such as the duality of Page 3 audience and so on. When i gave him an example of another not-so-successful movie 'Tango Charlie' which also showed many novel things for the first time, he did not reply. Not so surprisingly, his second movie with the same director and crew failed at the box office. When Farhan Akthar was asked in a TV interview why his second movie 'Lakhshya' did not run well, ( after his smash hit of Dil chahta Hai) he was candid enough to say that 'he does not know the reason'.


This is what happens when individuals evaluate a 'whole' by looking at the fragments. One can evaluate a movie only as a whole. And one has to be trained to see the movie as a whole. A lay audience can only tell you whether they liked or not, but you need a trained expert in 'wholistic' systems to evaluate a movie. So whether you are evaluating Rang de basanti, Eklavya, Chakde, or Honeymoon travels, you need to get trained appropriately.

The same is true about evaluating an organisation as a whole. Business analysts are so eager to evaluate a company from its 'ad campaign' or its 'announced strategy' that they can rarely understand why that company runs well.

Thursday, August 10, 2006

Can a film's fate be predicted before its release?

Can someone predict that a couple is going to get divorced by listening them talk to each other for an hour ?

John Gottman, a researcher of University of Washington, can predict it for American couples with 95% accuracy. He has published it in a book called The Mathematics of divorce.

When someone is trying to 'unravel' a 'whole' like a relationship, one can employ two ways. One can break the 'whole' into simple components and try to 'strengthen' each of the elements, sequentially or simultaneously. Or one can view the 'whole' in a 'systemic' way, and find out a different 'way' of viewing the whole that can 'explain' that 'whole system' in a better way.

John Gottman took the second approach to predict a relationship graph of a couple. He viewed the 'whole' through a different window of +ve emotion and -ve emotion, and found that if the +ve emotions in a conversation are 'x' multiple of -ve emotion, then the relationship between the two people can be predicted.

One can employ a similar technique while 'evaluating' a whole, called 'Movie'. One can bifurcate a movie into different components like marketing, story-engaging capability and style of movie presentation. Each component can then be understood as a 'whole' and coupled together to predict a movie's success or failure.

It seems Ramesh Sarda, a professor of Oklahama State University, has gone this route and found out the clues of how marketing affects a movies success, and developed his predictive model. He developed concepts of 'prosumer' - a common concept of advertising - to make his point.

I also know of another researcher, Ravi Reddy (also from US), who has tried to evaluate the movie's impact on the audience through 'measuring' emotions of an audience. He has tried to use the new science of bioinformatics to measure the audience response directly by putting electrodes on the brain and other parts of the body. Here the idea is to measure the impact of the two elements - story engaging capability and style of presenting the movie - by measuring the 'emotional response' of an individual.

But both these researchers are trying to 'catch' the horse after it has bolted from the stable. One can predict a movie's success only after considerable money has been invested. It would be more effective if we can predict success of a movie after a script is ready. This is what Madhur Bhandarkar seem to have asked in the TOI news of 10 August, 'Can one predict a movies success after a script is ready?". My humble answer to that is yes.

One can do it by taking two actions:

  • Develop a method to understand the story-engaging capability of a movie. This can be done by marrying 'literature principles' with 'systemic thinking'. Both the bodies of knowledge are ready and available. One needs a person to marry them both. This is fairly 'simple' task, a task of 2 months.
  • Use a trained and experienced 'director' - like Madhur Bhandarkar or Ram Gopal Verma - to understand how the story written in a 'specific' way can be converted into a movie. This can be done by an experienced director. Once again, an appropriately trained director can unravel this code in a short period, say 2 months.

Both the above actions require an ability to 'unravel' the whole 'movie' without breaking 'whole' into components. And therefore it requires experience and technical knowledge together.

However, if we can bring these two components together, we could definitely built a 'method' of predicting a movie-success with a probabilty of say 70% or more. Naturally, such methods are part 'science' and part 'art'. But with experience, the predictability can be increased to even higher rates.

This will not only help us make good movies, but will also help us rope in better financers for movie. This will prevent the wastage of money in movie projects. This will increase the ability of a movie to fetch back normal returns.

All this knowledge is available in India. It may not be available in movie industry, but is available in corporate India.

Does any one in a movie industry have courage to follow this path? With more professionalisation, i am sure someone will have the courage to bell the tiger.