Monday, January 24, 2011

Dhobi Ghat - Power of theme in movie making

Dhobi Ghat, a film directed by Kiran Rao, is a good movie. Characterisation is excellent, plot/story about four different characters is equally good, style of presenting is equally wonderful. Many facets of the movie are excellent: Weaving of four characters, intelligent use of the video of a girl as an intrigue, use of Zoib's character to keep the story engaging.

But it lacks just one thing - Theme. Without a theme, the movie seems to be a documentary.

Theme is an often invisible in a movie. But any good movie ( and more so if it becomes popular) always has a underlying theme to which the entire plot/character/style has to align. Sometimes this theme is mentioned in a line of a character in a movie( like in 3 idiots), sometimes it has to be deciphered. 3 idiots became popular because it's central theme is so clearly brought out through the story. This line given to Aamir Khan ' Kabliyat ke piche Daudo, shohrat khud-b-khud tumaraa pichaa karegi' captures the movies theme very aptly. Entire structure of movie is built around that central theme.

Raj kapoor's movies were popular because his central theme was presented through two plots: one a social plot, and another a story plot. Example of Ram Teri Ganga Maili is an excellent example of this.

Dhobi Ghat lacks this central theme. Let us take an example of a theme that would have connected with the audience,such as, 'Mumbai helps everyone to realise their dreams irrespective of its bottlenecks'. End of movie could have strengthened this theme, but changes in certain dialogues would be needed to bring out his theme starkly. The story of fourth character ( the character of girl who commits suicide) would not have fitted this theme. Some changes would have been needed in the movie to make the above theme work.

That is what a theme does to the movie. It clearly brings out what is 'right and logical' in a movie and what is not. It provides consistency to the characters. It anchors the plot. And above all, in the mind of a audience, it connects with something bigger in life.

No comments: