Friday, February 19, 2010

MNIK - a lost opportunity of conveying a powerful theme

The movie starts with a wonderful scene at the airport security. When Rizwan, the hero, is asked by the police what he wants to tell the President, he says " My name is Khan & I am not a terrorist'. This scene is done with such a finesse that it shakes one up from the stupor. It also carries lot of impact because it perhaps articulates an unspoken thought of each and every individual in a very neat and simple way.

Although the love story is another subplot in the story, subtle seeds of impending climax of movie are also sown at different places in the plot. When Rizwans's child dies due to unexpected but 'inevitable' incident, the story becomes more gripping. This event is a beautiful example of 'how to tell a good story', because within a single event, both the plots converge. The conflict between wife's love and the hero's identity is brought out in the open!

Till, almost the 2/3rd of the movie, the story continues with the minor plot ( love story) subsumed under the main plot( of Hero's identity). Until the TV broadcast of the hero's detainment in the prison, the story grips you with emotion and drama. The event of the TV broadcast would have been appropriate to convey the main theme of MNIK 'My name is Khan and i am not a terrorist' to the president.

But the director suddenly forgets that main plot of the story is of Muslim identity. The director decides that the plot of 'love story' is more important and therefore continues to tell us the story further. It is like our nanny continuing to narrate a murder mystery after the culprit has been caught. One naturally feels bored because one is then hearing the story out of respect to Nanny.

In a movie with such a strong theme, such a mistake is felt strongly because the important message gets 'submerged' under a trivial message. One almost feels cheated because the story, which started with a grand promise, is delivering some other promise.I wish Karan Johar learns the critical elements of a good story-telling. He is so gifted in his ability to capture emotions, portray relationships, deploy camera so beautifully, that one wishes he learns this very simple element of story- telling quickly. I will not be surprised if the movie does not become a 'huge hit' that it deserved to be!

Here is a Quiz for you. Few years back, another director, also made the same mistake:making a movie with two themes, each clashing with other. That movie flopped very badly. But that director had directed his first movie, which was a huge hit. Can you name the director and his second movie which flopped?

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

You are right. It seemed all right for an hour or so. But past that jail scene, Karan Johar gave it - what you can call a typical Bollywood tadka!!! Also Khan's Georgia detour when he was on his way from California to DC.. was plain ridiculous!