Yesterday, i saw this Japanese Movie of 1960, directed by Kaneto Shindo. It is amazing because of four reasons:
1> The director has the audacity to chose a theme that is almost impossible to show on the screen. The theme is "Despite huge struggles to live, life still goes on". Protagonist of theme is the farmer living in an island where there is no water. The family ( consisting of husband, wife and two sons) has to bring in water from a nearby town everyday in a boat even to meet their daily needs like taking bath or drinking water. And then we are surprised to see that they also are carrying water to feed the the plants on which they are subsisting. The struggle is of physical survival, something an Indian farmer in the hinterland can still identify himself with.
2> The film has no spoken dialogue. Although there is background music, the silence is deliberate. Only later, we discover the powerful impact of silence. The silence mirrors the patience and the hard work of a farmer and, like him, we tend to understand that one cannot expect swift results in life. Even the children are shown doing their household tasks without being told so. The director seem to have made the actors actually carry the huge water, because we can see the struggle of the man/woman in trying to grip the ground, in maintaining the balance between the two pots of water. Silence makes us imagine their thoughts and struggle better than anyone can tell us. And therefore it contributes greatly to the film’s stoic attitude to the hardships of life.
3> The film has a simple plot. Entire plot conveys the same theme again and again. For instance, after the harvest when the farmer and his wife takes it to the nearby town, they just keep the harvest infront of the house of some 'rich agent' and walk way, not even negotiating the price of harvest. Or when the son catches a big fish, the family is very happy. However, when they are eating their food in a restaurant ( as part of their celebration), their manner of eating is very 'workman-like'. They seem to be knowing that struggle is still to continue.
4> And in the climax, when one of the son dies, the despair is shown in the wife. She breaks down. She kicks the pot of water and spills the entire water after carrying it for miles, and then removes the plants from the earth. We can sense her despairing thought, "How long can I go on living like this? Is there an end to this?" With no words from her mouth, we can almost read the thoughts in her mind.
I remembered Irving Wallace, the famous novelist, who said that " Written novels can never be converted into good films, because films cannot use your imagination like written novels can". But when you watch this Kaneto Shindo's movie, Naked Island, you realise that he proved this wrong.
Conclusion
And although the movie plot portrays physical struggle', the movie's theme is still relevant today. Only the nature of struggle has changed. Today, our struggle in the modern 21st century is more 'mental'. We are not seeking physical comfort. That phase of life is over. We are seeking mental comfort. For instance, we want to find job satisfaction in our life, or do something significant in life, or leave behind some legacy. And, like the farmer in Naked Island, we continue to 'Live our Life despite the struggles, pains, failures, and the hiccups'.
Today, because the struggle is 'mental', one cannot see this struggle in the open. One can at least watch the physical struggle and empathise with a person, but how can one empathise with a person whose mental struggle can be seen only by himself. If Kaneto Shindo was called in to direct a movie to show this acute'mental struggle', which many students suffer either due to their school negligence or parental expectations, how would he have shown?
4> And in the climax, when one of the son dies, the despair is shown in the wife. She breaks down. She kicks the pot of water and spills the entire water after carrying it for miles, and then removes the plants from the earth. We can sense her despairing thought, "How long can I go on living like this? Is there an end to this?" With no words from her mouth, we can almost read the thoughts in her mind.
I remembered Irving Wallace, the famous novelist, who said that " Written novels can never be converted into good films, because films cannot use your imagination like written novels can". But when you watch this Kaneto Shindo's movie, Naked Island, you realise that he proved this wrong.
Conclusion
And although the movie plot portrays physical struggle', the movie's theme is still relevant today. Only the nature of struggle has changed. Today, our struggle in the modern 21st century is more 'mental'. We are not seeking physical comfort. That phase of life is over. We are seeking mental comfort. For instance, we want to find job satisfaction in our life, or do something significant in life, or leave behind some legacy. And, like the farmer in Naked Island, we continue to 'Live our Life despite the struggles, pains, failures, and the hiccups'.
Today, because the struggle is 'mental', one cannot see this struggle in the open. One can at least watch the physical struggle and empathise with a person, but how can one empathise with a person whose mental struggle can be seen only by himself. If Kaneto Shindo was called in to direct a movie to show this acute'mental struggle', which many students suffer either due to their school negligence or parental expectations, how would he have shown?
